A. T. Stewart Exchange Consignment Shop
Parking Lot Pick-up
Monday - Friday: 10 a.m. - 12:00 p.m.
109 Eleventh Street
Garden City, New York 11530
(Entrance and parking at the rear of the Museum)
During the Historical Society's 2007 Flea Market an idea was born. Kris Harder, a GCHS Trustee, proposed a consignment shop on the premises to provide a new and different shop for local residents and visitors to enjoy. And the beneficiary would be the GCHS. Kris put together a small group of volunteers to staff the A.T. Stewart Exchange Consignment Shop, as it has become known. Today, we number almost 30 volunteers!
May 28, 2020 Update! Consistent with the Governor's phased approach to re-opening, the Exchange will remain closed for the time being. However, we will be open for parking lot or in-store pick-ups of items purchase at our online store, or reserved via email or phone. Monday - Friday 10:00am - 12:00pm, or by appointment. Wear your masks! We'll be wearing ours.
The Exchange is perfect for those who are down-sizing. Consignments (and donations) are accepted every day, except Saturdays, and consignors are paid 50% of the selling price. Unsure about whether your items are appropriate for consignment? Call the Shop! Better yet, show us your digital photos or email us at
Furnishing a new home? The Exchange is also a perfect place to shop. We have many beautiful items at great prices!
A few of the Exchange Volunteers at the 2019 Gala
With your support, TGCHS is being painted & restored