Garden City, New York 11530 (Entrance and parking at the rear of the Museum)
During the Historical Society's 2007 Flea Market an idea was born. Kris Harder, a GCHS Trustee, proposed a consignment shop on the premises to provide a new and different shop for local residents and visitors to enjoy. And the beneficiary would be the GCHS. Kris put together a small group of volunteers to staff the A.T. Stewart Exchange Consignment Shop, as it has become known. Today, we number almost 30 volunteers!
A few of the A.T. Stewart Exchange Volunteers at the 2019 Gala (above) and the NY Gift Show (bottom left).
We are open year-round. Perfect for those who are down-sizing. Consignments (and donations) are accepted every day, except Saturdays, and consignors are paid 50% of the selling price. Unsure about whether your items are appropriate for consignment? Call the Shop! Better yet, show us your digital photos or email us at
Furnishing a new home? The Exchange is also a perfect place to shop. We have many beautiful items at great prices!